New Eagle Insurance is an independent insurance agency. Our goal is to provide you with the best coverage for your premium dollar. We do not work for an insurance company; we work for you.
Property & Casualty
- Motorcycle, ATV, Boat, Snowmobile, Camper
- Personal Umbrella
- Business Owners Policies
- Workers Compensation
- General Liability
- Commercial Umbrella
- Business Auto
- All other property or liability coverage
Life & Health
- Individual/Family Health Insurance
- Individual Life Insurance
- Individual Disability Insurance
- Medicare Supplement/Prescription Insurance
- Group Health/Dental
- Group Life
- Group Disability
- All other benefits related to life or health insurance
In 1972 Harold Buchheit started Harry’s Tax Service with the goal in mind to help out his friends and family. He always prided himself in providing top notch service with a personal touch. This philosophy catapulted the company’s growth. Harry’s son, Dennis, joined him in 1993 and the company name was changed to Buchheit Tax Service in 2008.
Driven to uphold the standards of providing top notch service with a personal touch that his father created, Dennis wanted to broaden the scope of services for their loyal customers. Fortunate to find a staff that shares the family philosophy, Dennis opened the insurance division in 2011 offering multiple product lines of insurance and financial planning services.
At New Eagle Insurance, we enjoy the work we do and are excited to provide any service to our loyal customers, friends, families and our future customers. We offer free insurance quotes to individuals and businesses and we are dedicated to great customer service. We believe that the key to success begins and ends with careful and honest service.
Toben Murdock, of New Eagle Insurance and Financial Services, specializes in home, auto and commercial insurance. From negotiating complex coverages to patiently answering any lingering questions, he is passionate about helping people like you get the best possible insurance at the best possible price. For your friendly, professional, and free consultation, contact Toben today.
John K. Splinter
John K. Splinter
John Splinter specializes in home and auto insurance. Prior to joining New Eagle Insurance & Financial Services, he was employed at Prudential Financial. John looks forward to helping you find the right insurance choice for you. For your home and auto insurance needs, contact John today.
Angie Coleman looks forward to helping you with your home and auto insurance needs. She will work to find the insurance company that fits your lifestyle and pocketbook. To start saving today, contact Angie for your free quote.
Donna began working with New Eagle Insurance & Financial Services in October 2012. Prior to this, she was a Sr. Sale Representative for The McGraw-Hill Companies for 16 years. She is currently licensed for Personal Lines insurance. She hopes to get her Health/Life license in the very near future. Away from the office, Donna enjoys spending time with her husband, Kevin, and children. She has two step-children (ages 28 and 23,) a 19-year son, and a 5-year old son. She enjoys walking, spending time outdoors, and the comfort of family and friends.
Jeff began his insurance career in 2007 and is licensed in Life, Health, and Personal lines insurance. He specializes in group worksite benefits and enjoys helping companies make customized product recommendations based on the client’s goals and needs. In his free time Jeff enjoys attending his children’s many sporting events, golfing, and the great outdoors.
Nathan has been an insurance agent since 2012 and is licensed to sell home and auto insurance. With a background in business management, Nathan is also a Realtor working through New Eagle Realty and is licensed to sell real estate in Iowa. He also works as a Tax Consultant with Buchheit Tax Service. Nathan takes a big picture approach when working with both personal and business clients on insurance, real estate and tax planning issues and firmly believes that the most important goal is to provide many valuable services throughout each year of a client’s life and help them reach their goals while forging a lifetime relationship. Nathan was born and raised in Dubuque and has been married to his wonderful wife, Jen, for over 14 years. They have two beautiful children, Jacob is 11 and loves football and video games and Leah is 4 and loves Dora and giving big squeezy hugs.
Tim Frith, of New Eagle Insurance & Financial Services, specializes in home and auto insurance. Tim is currently working on obtaining his commercial license to increase his service to the broader business community. Prior to joining New Eagle Insurance & Financial Services, Tim dedicated the last 25 years to the service industry gaining the trust of the tri-state area communities. Tim is dedicated and confident in his abilities to find the right insurance at a competitive price to meet all of your insurance needs.
Zach D. Hinkel of New Eagle Insurance and Financial Services specializes in personal home and auto insurance. Born and raised in Dubuque, IA, Zach attended the University of Dubuque graduating in 2012 with a bachelor’s degree in business and accounting. With his enthusiasm for helping people save money and his fresh take on the business world Zach is the perfect fit to meet your insurance needs.
I joined Buchheit Tax Service in December 2011 as the Client Relations Specialist. In 2002 I graduated from Hawkeye Community College in Waterloo. My family and I moved back to Dubuque in November 2011. Since we have been back we welcomed our second daughter in October of 2013. I am excited to get to know all of our clients and work with the excellent staff.
Nick Davis was born and raised in Dubuque, IA. He is licensed in both personal and commercial lines of insurance, so he enjoys identifying the needs of his customers, whether for personal or business purposes, and delivering solutions for those needs. Nick graduated from the University of Iowa with a Bachelor’s Degree in Business Management, so in addition to gaining knowledge of the business world, he also became a big Iowa Hawkeyes football fan. He likes watching sports and spending his free time enjoying the outdoors, especially if it includes golf or fishing.
Property and Casualty
We have the ability to receive quotes from over 25 top ranking Property and Casualty carriers. Once we receive your information, our staff will request quotes with as many carriers as possible. This will assure you the best rate for the coverage you request. Your agent will contact you with your personalized proposal. If you have any questions, one of our insurance specialists will be happy to assist you.
To start saving today and receive your free quote, call us at (563) 582-5834 or simply fill out the secure online form.
Life, Health, and Financial Services
We are proud to offer to our customers:
I want to let you know how much I appreciate you taking the time to contact a lawyer and for going above and beyond the call of duty. I will be an advocate for you and your business. I have never had a company be so empowering. I really do appreciate all your time, talents and kindness. Thank you again!! You are the best!!!
Donna is very knowledgeable and helpful. Kelly at the front desk gives one of the best first impressions of any business I have ever entered. There is definitely a team mentality and it shows. I feel like our business is valued and appreciated and that is very important to me!
Toben and his team at New Eagle Group have been there with answers to my questions as I have needed them and worked to provide me with the best coverage for my insurance needs.
It’s great dealing with Toben, when ever I purchase a new vehicle everything is taken care of the instant I walk in the door. Any questions I ever have are always taken care of right away, much appreciated!!
Prompt service and great pricing.
The service which Eagle Group provides is outstanding.
I made a quick move to a rental requiring immediate insurance. Toben researched the appropriate coverage at an affordable rate in a quick turn around time, allowing me peace of mind knowing I had protection. He called inquiring whether I had questions and left information about the company. Thank you Toben.